academic-paper-reviewer
Multi-perspective academic paper review with dynamic reviewer personas
by imbad0202Free
Description
Academic Paper Reviewer simulates an international journal peer review of a paper. It first identifies the paper's field, then sets up a panel of five review seats. Four are card-backed identities: a Journal-Fit Reviewer and three peer reviewers who cover methodology, domain expertise and cross-disciplinary views. The fifth is a fixed Devil's Advocate, which challenges the core argument, detects logical fallacies and identifies the strongest counter-arguments. A separate editorial synthesizer then produces a structured Editorial Decision and a Revision Roadmap, so the reviewers' views and the final decision are kept apart. The skill has a re-review mode for checking whether a revised paper answers the reviewers' comments. The panel was expanded from four members to five in version 1.1, and the page lists version 1.11.1 for this release. The skill follows the same routing rules as the other academic skills in the repository, with an escape hatch for messages that begin with a direct-mode token. Use it when you want a paper critiqued from several angles before you submit it.…
Highlights
- Five-seat review panel with distinct roles
- Journal-fit reviewer and three peer reviewers
- Devil's Advocate challenges the core argument
- Editorial Decision and Revision Roadmap
- Re-review mode to check revisions
Ratings & Reviews
No ratings yet
Be the first to rate academic-paper-reviewer.
People also visit
academic-pipeline
Orchestrator for the full academic research pipeline: research -> write ->
nature-reviewer
Provide evidence-grounded mock peer review of scientific manuscripts or
academic-paper-review
The user requests to review, analyze, critique, or summarize academic papers
nature-response
Draft, audit, or revise responses to peer review, revision cover letters
academic-paper-reviewer FAQ
What does it review?
A paper, from a simulated international journal review. It identifies the paper's field and sets up the review panel to suit it.
Who is on the panel?
A Journal-Fit Reviewer, three peer reviewers covering methodology, domain expertise and cross-disciplinary views, and a fixed Devil's Advocate.
What does the output look like?
A structured Editorial Decision and a Revision Roadmap from a separate editorial synthesizer.
Can it check a revised paper?
Yes. Its re-review mode checks whether the revisions address the reviewers' comments.
How do I install it?
Run npx skills add https://github.com/imbad0202/academic-research-skills --skill academic-paper-reviewer.
Is it free?
The listing shows it as free. The source is in the imbad0202/academic-research-skills repository on GitHub.
What are the best academic-paper-reviewer alternatives?
Popular alternatives to academic-paper-reviewer include academic-paper, academic-pipeline and nature-reviewer. See all academic-paper-reviewer alternatives