scholar-evaluation
Structured scholarly-work evaluation for papers, proposals, literature reviews
by affaan-mFree
Description
scholar-evaluation is an agent skill from the ECC collection by affaan-m, listed on skills.sh. It evaluates academic and scientific work against a repeatable rubric. It applies to reviewing a research paper, proposal, thesis chapter or literature review, to checking whether the claims in a piece of work are supported by its cited evidence, to assessing methodology, study design, analysis and stated limitations, to comparing two or more papers for quality or relevance, and to producing structured feedback that an author can use in a revision. The skill starts by identifying the artefact and its scope, so the review matches what is actually being assessed. Because it is a SKILL.md file of instructions, an AI agent loads it when such a review is requested and follows the same structure each time. It is free and open source, and the skills.sh listing shows a Snyk warning, with Gen Agent Trust Hub and Socket passing.…
Highlights
- Repeatable rubric for scholarly work
- Checks claims against cited evidence
- Methodology and limitations review
- Structured feedback for revision
Ratings & Reviews
No ratings yet
Be the first to rate scholar-evaluation.
People also visit
scholar-evaluation FAQ
What does the scholar-evaluation skill do?
It reviews academic work such as papers, proposals and literature reviews against a rubric and returns structured feedback.
Does it check citations?
It checks whether claims are supported by the evidence cited for them.
Can it compare papers?
Yes. Comparing two or more papers for quality or relevance is one of its listed uses.
How do I install it?
Run: npx skills add https://github.com/affaan-m/ecc --skill scholar-evaluation
Is it free?
Yes. It is free and open source.
Are there security warnings?
The skills.sh listing shows Snyk with a warning, while Gen Agent Trust Hub and Socket pass.
What are the best scholar-evaluation alternatives?
Popular alternatives to scholar-evaluation include content-research-writer, pdf and research. See all scholar-evaluation alternatives